Something you need to know, if we are to get to know one another, is that I have many issues with the current and established Evangelical church. A few other things that should be brought to light; I am only 24 so most of what I say is probably still filled with a childhood of naivety and an intellectual adolescents of cynicism. Also it is important to preface my next few statements and concerns with the knowledge that I attended a Christian University, an excellent learning institution known by Hardin-Simmons University. While attending HSU (as we will call it) it was mandatory that every single student attend at least 40 Chapel Sessions each semester. Chapel was usually a student lead worship experience or a guest speaker who came to educate or preach a message that was supposedly important to the academic growth of HSU. While still attending Chapel sessions in my sophomore year at school, I became an intern at a local church in town; I would end up serving that church in a ministerial capacity for about three years. It served as a wonderful learning experience, in many helpful and some tragic ways. I learned some very basic principles about serving in a Southern Baptist Convention church; more importantly I learned about what drives the Southern Baptist Evangelical mindset, but that isn’t the point of this post. Rather than attacking the hydra in one fell swoop, I would like to touch on a culture point in this post.
I would like to air out some thoughts on Youth Praise and Worship, in so far as my experience has shown me.
1. Emotion against Discipline.
A vast amount of the music groups that ‘Christian’ youth groups listen to are carbon copy versions of Pop-Culture icons. Do not jump to conclusions about what I am going to say about the Christian music business. No I don’t think that they are all money grubbing fake-o’s who couldn’t make it in the real music industry, that would be a judgment call and the Self-Defeating Man (while self-defeating to himself) strives not to make those types of judgments. But I am sure we have all seen the Christian promo packets that say,
“If you like (insert famous pop-culture group) then you may just love (insert Christian music group who happens to sound somewhat like previously mentioned group), but because (Christian group mentioned) loves God and their music is actually pleasing to God!”
It isn’t a group of concerned Christians trying to get kids to listen to positive and Christ centered music.
It’s merchandising. (Every time I write that line I think of the scenes with Mel Brooks as the Yoda parody in Spaceballs. ‘SPACE BALLS THE FLAME THROWER!!! The kids love it.’)
And so kids listen to this music which is filled with modulations, originally put in music to make people believe they were having a spirit filled listening experience and go to laser light shows that always end in an altar call. I can just see some C.E.O. pitching the idea to a group of business people.
CEO: “Ok, here’s the deal, we get these 14-18 year old kids all jacked up on emotion, soda and indoctrination, then we have the band make an altar call at the end of the show. BANG, kids get saved.”
Concerned Partner: “Shouldn’t the choice also be about understanding the calling that Christ sets before all people? I mean didn’t Christ say to weigh the cost before taking up his calling?”
CEO: “Oh sure Larry, if you take them out of the emotional atmosphere, how the hell are you going to get them to buy the t-shirts, cds, and then sign up for emotional mission trips to Colorado, where a the youth team does 3 hours of service to a small needy church and Ski’s for 3 days afterward?”
Concerned Partner: “Well, what happens when we send these kids home, the emotion wears off and the hard questions start being asked, are we just supposed to get them hyped and offer no substance? I mean 99% of these kids don’t know how the Bible was written, who it was written by and 99.99% don’t understand what the point of the Christian life is.”
CEO: “What’s your point Larry?”
Concerned Partner: “Shouldn’t children understand the oath they are undertaking, before they sign themselves up to be representatives of the Living God? Who calls them not only to repentance but to activism, social peacekeeping, and love? And you want them to surrender all that based on a Friday night’s emotional binge? Isn’t that irresponsible?”
CEO: “Larry, I think you and I should have a talk after the meeting.”
It seems to me, that most evangelical churches send their kids away to emotional summer
camps, not to be taught how to read or understand the Bible, but rather to just accept all
its words to be true, culturally and socially. It sounds more like Propaganda and less like
the good news of the gospel. What happened to the idea that worship was a discipline? Not Friday night at a Casting Crowns concert. ( BTW, I like Casting Crowns, alot.) Isn’t is something more?
Isn’t it about praising God with silence while you plant seeds and watch the vegetation grow? Thanking God that you have been blessed beyond measure, and instead of going to that 60$ a ticket show, you are going to sponser a needy child?
More to Come on this.
-C.S.